Bato apologises for defending secret cell; suggests tying suspects to posts instead

station 1 chr jail visit part1 apr272017 006 65ED6440246B4E1D950DA14DBB20B827
The secret cell found hidden behind a bookcase at a Manila police station last week

Police chief Ronald has apologised after defending the use of an illegal and unconstitutional secret cell at a Manila police station.

The leader of the Philippine National Police (PNP) said he “got emotional” and just wanted to defend his fellow officers, who he described as his “children”.


However, he has continued to maintain that the cell — which was hidden behind a bookcase — was merely a “creative” response to overcrowding.

He added that in future the problem should be dealt with by tying suspects to posts or railings, so no accusations of secret detention can been made.

As we reported, the shocking discovery was made by the Commission on Human Rights (CHR) last Thursday, when they found 12 men and women crammed into a tiny, squalid cell hidden at a police station in Tondo.


After the PNP was criticised for the illegal practice, Dela Rosa sparked further anger when he defended the police involved, insisting that allegations of abuse, extortion and arbitrary detention against them were false.

He also lashed out at the CHR, saying their visit was “for show” and intended to embarrass the government and police in the run up to the ASEAN Summit.

Chito Gascon of the CHR said Dela Rosa’s remarks showed “personal ignorance of both the constitutional and legal provisions that expressly prohibit the maintenance of secret detention facilities by public authorities.”

But Dela Rosa reiterated his defence of his cops on Monday, saying the detainees lied to the CHR about their plight because they hoped to be released.

Bato and Bato
The colourful police chief has apologised for his initial defence of his officers, but now suggests they should tie suspects to railings or posts as a better way to ease overcrowding

However today (Wednesday, May 3) he appeared to backtrack on his earlier remarks. He said: “We are all Filipinos. We are all against human suffering. Those detained there, they really suffered. So we have to act on it. So we will talk. I’ll find a way.

“Sorry to the CHR if I was very emotional. It’s only natural for a father to defend his children as long as there’s basis. So I apologise.”

He has also ordered a full inventory of police cells to close down any further hidden jails.

Despite this apology and promise of action, he maintains that his officers were not acting maliciously — but had merely found the wrong solution to an overcrowding problem.

He said: “I told them if the jail is really filled to capacity, you’ll have no choice but to tie the detainees to the posts inside your station or to the railing just so they are unable to escape. As long as they’re visible. We’re transparent. We’ll see what happens if we’re transparent even when it comes to the inhumane situations in jails.”

Dela Rosa has led the PNP since President Duterte’s accession in July 2016. He was previously head of Davao City police under Mr Duterte’s mayoralty.